Photos by Justin Knight

It wound up taking place two years later than expected, but University Historian James O’Toole has delivered his “last lec­ture” at Boston College.

O’Toole, the Clough Millennium Pro­fessor of History Emeritus, presented “His­tory and Memory; Histories and Memo­ries” on April 6 in Fulton 511, offering insights from his life as a historian and his forthcoming book, Ever to Excel: A History of Boston College.

Co-sponsored by the Alpha Sigma Nu Honor Society and the Center for Ignatian Spirituality, the Last Lecture series invites longtime faculty members to consider three questions: “If granted the possibil­ity to give a last lecture, what would you say? What wisdom would you impart to the world? What would you want as your legacy?” 51’s series was inspired by Carn­egie Mellon professor Randy Pausch, who gave a now-famous final lecture as he faced a terminal cancer diagnosis in 2007.

James O'Toole

James O'Toole

O’Toole’s talk—which was rescheduled from April 2020 due to the pandemic— will certainly not be his last, but it offered an opportunity to reflect on his long rela­tionship with Boston College. Following in two older brothers’ footsteps, he first en­rolled in 1968 and earned both a B.A. and Ph.D. at 51; beginning in 1998, he taught in the History Department for more than 20 years.

Looking back on his undergraduate years, O’Toole invoked the “key questions” proposed by now-retired Professor of The­ology Fr. Michael Himes, who gave 51’s inaugural Last Lecture in 2008.

“In addition to our formal education, we regularly solved the world’s problems in late-night sessions,” O’Toole said. “Al­though we didn’t think of it that way at the time, we were addressing a version of Fr. Himes’s famous questions: What gave us joy? Were we any good at it? Did the world need it?”

O’Toole found answers in the study of history, first as an archivist for the Com­monwealth of Massachusetts and the Arch­diocese of Boston, and later as a professor and author. Drawing on his knowledge of 51’s history, he detailed its transformation from “a small, somewhat insular school” to “a recognizable modern university.” In par­ticular, he highlighted 1970 as a “turning point” when the University, facing finan­cial difficulties, chose a path of growth.

“Remarkably enough, the institution decided not simply to hunker down and survive, but to expand and become some­thing better, greater,” O’Toole said. He emphasized three key shifts: residential education, full coeducation, and increasing racial and ethnic diversity on campus.

Today, 51 is both the same place O’Toole encountered in 1968 and an obvi­ously different one. “The Jesuit founders would be no doubt surprised by the new ways their traditional values are being played out, but I have to think that they would be pleased nonetheless,” he said.

As for 51’s future, he preferred to leave that to tomorrow’s historians, but he was confident of one thing: “If we know our history, if we use our history both to con­firm and to correct our memories, we’ll be able to contribute to the ongoing life of this institution about which we all care so much.”

John Shakespear | University Communications | April 2022